These are my personal rankings based on standard 5×5 roto categories.
| Rank | Player | Age | Team | NFBC ADP |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Adley Rutschman | 26 | Orioles | 53.27 |
| 2. | William Contreras | 26 | Brewers | 72.82 |
| 3. | J.T. Realmuto | 33 | Phillies | 87 |
| 4. | Will Smith | 29 | Dodgers | 87.49 |
| 5. | Yanier Diaz | 25 | Astros | 117.57 |
| 6. | Cal Raleigh | 27 | Mariners | 142.8 |
| 7. | Willson Contreras | 32 | Cardinals | 144.51 |
| 8. | Sean Murphy | 29 | Braves | 154.33 |
| 9. | Francisco Alvarez | 22 | Mets | 149.02 |
| 10. | Salvador Perez | 34 | Royals | 145.51 |
| 11. | Jonah Heim | 29 | Rangers | 174.02 |
| 12. | Gabriel Moreno | 24 | Diamondbacks | 153 |
| 13. | Keibert Ruiz | 25 | Nationals | 174.92 |
| 14. | Logan O’Hoppe | 24 | Angels | 169.98 |
| 15. | Bo Naylor | 24 | Guardians | 165.49 |
| 16. | Mitch Garver | 33 | Mariners | 210.69 |
| 17. | Luis Campusano | 25 | Padres | 208.33 |
| 18. | Alejandro Kirk | 25 | Blue Jays | 269.88 |
| 19. | Tyler Stephenson | 27 | Reds | 228.71 |
| 20. | Elias Diaz | 33 | Rockies | 258.78 |
| 21. | Shea Langeliers | 26 | Athletics | 262.76 |
| 22. | Danny Jansen | 29 | Blue Jays | 266.63 |
| 23. | Ryan Jeffers | 27 | Twins | 264.43 |
| 24. | Travis d’Arnaud | 35 | Braves | 376.94 |
| 25. | Yan Gomes | 35 | Cubs | 372.43 |
| 26. | Austin Wells | 24 | Yankees | 298.9 |
| 27. | Connor Wong | 28 | Red Sox | 357.43 |
| 28. | Jake Rogers | 29 | Tigers | 342 |
| 29. | Patrick Bailey | 25 | Giants | 356.45 |
| 30. | Freddy Fermin | 29 | Royals | 392.8 |
| 31. | Gary Sanchez | 31 | Padres | 442.49 |
| 32. | Rene Pinto | 27 | Rays | 448.22 |
| 33. | Blake Sabol | 26 | Giants | 469.55 |
| 34. | Miguel Amaya | 25 | Cubs | 481.61 |
| 35. | Ivan Herrera | 24 | Cardinals | 497.27 |
| 36. | Christian Bethancourt | 32 | Marlins | 498.27 |
| 37. | Christian Vazquez | 34 | Twins | 539.47 |
| 38. | Nick Fortes | 27 | Marlins | 542.9 |
| 39. | Korey Lee | 25 | White Sox | 547.57 |
| 40. | Tom Murphy | 32 | Giants | 578.96 |